CS547 Human-Computer Interaction Seminar   (Seminar on People, Computers, and Design)

Fridays 11:30am-12:30pm PT · Gates B3 · Open to the public
Previous | Next
Todd Davies
Stanford Symbolic Systems Program
Designing for Deliberation
January 20, 2006

Asynchronous communication tools such as email, message boards, blogs, and
wikis are convenient for many types of two-way communication, even for large
groups. For small, technically skilled, or very like-minded groups, they can
even be serviceable for deliberative decision making of the kind that is associated
with face-to-face meetings. When these tools do not lend themselves to group
decision making and a face-to-face meeting is impossible or inconvenient,
then synchronous communication -- e.g. commercial meeting software, or combining
IRC with a pastebin, or conference calling as participants sit at their computers
-- can often suffice for deliberation. But this leaves a large class of situations,
which I will describe, in which groups need or would like to deliberate online
but do not have good tools for doing so.
Deme (pronounced "deem") is a free and open web-based tool that
we are designing to help fill this deliberative gap. It is being built for
groups like the advisory boards, consortia of small nonprofits, block clubs,
and residents' committees that we have worked with as part of the Partnership
for Internet Equity and Community Engagement (PIECE), a joint project of the
East Palo Alto Community Network and the Symbolic Systems Program at Stanford.
A set of characteristics shared by these groups is very common in civil society,
and if better tools could be developed to help them organize, set priorities,
and mobilize, the result could be democratizing in areas such as community
planning, labor unions, faith communities, service organizations, political
advocacy, and academic life.
I will describe the assumptions underlying Deme, and some design choices
that follow from them. I will also attempt to situate our work within the
emerging, very interdisciplinary field of online deliberation. And I will
demonstrate some of Deme's capabilities as they exist in the current, alpha-stage
version. A new version, addressing user-friendliness through "AJAX"
and a redesigned interface, is in development and will be presented at CodeCon
2006 in February.
This is joint work with Brendan O'Connor, Alex Cochran, Andrew Parker, Ben
Newman, and Aaron Tam.


I began my career as a computer scientist in the Artificial Intelligence
Center at SRI International (1985-'91), working on topics such as learning
by analogy, commonsense reasoning, and neural networks. I studied the psychology
of judgment and decision making under Amos Tversky (Ph.D., Stanford, 1995),
taught psychology at Koc University in Istanbul (1996-'99), and returned to
Stanford in 2000 to be the coordinator and a lecturer in the Symbolic Systems
Program. Since my graduate student days, I have been involved in a number
of grassroots political groups, with a particular interest in how they make
decisions and could be organized more effectively. Since 2002, I have been
working with staff at the Plugged In community technology center in East Palo
Alto and with Stanford students to study and enhance community participation
there through the Internet. In 2005, I organized the Second Conference on
Online Deliberation: Design, Research, and Practice / DIAC-2005, held at Stanford,
and joined the board of Computer Professionals for Social Responsibility,
serving as Vice President. My general interests concern psychological and
technological approaches to group decision making and the foundations of collective
behavior.