CS547 Human-Computer Interaction Seminar   (Seminar on People, Computers, and Design)

Fridays 11:30am-12:30pm PT · Gates B3 · Open to the public
Previous | Next
Eviatar Shafrir
Hewlett-Packard
Information Playgrounds: Local Metaphors for Interactive Information A Visual Design Perspective
January 27, 1995

In August 1994, for the Stanford Research Workshop on the
World Wide Web, I wrote:

The World Wide Web has opened the door to InfoTravel. With
our favorite 'Mosaic' or 'Cello' brand InfoCars we take off and
explore InfoSpace. Whatever metaphor we use to describe our online
adventures, we are forced to experience them through the windshield
of this, that, or yet another aging Desktop. Furthermore, the
information exhibits behave as static Documents in Application
windows.

While each Desktop is populated with overlapping Windows,
displaying dynamic contents and of elastic size, our InfoCars
windshields expose us only to Documents where the contents are
tiled, scrolled, and static. In addition, we are not really travelling
since there is no continuous motion in HyperSpace. We can only
jump from one InfoStop to the next and most times without ample
guidance or expectation of what's ahead.

At each InfoStop the information itself is now active, hot,
and live. This creates an Interaction Dissonance between Desktop
behaviors (inside the InfoCar's Dashboard and around its windshield)
and local navigation and interaction metaphors unique to each
InfoStop (visible through the windshield). Since there is no
InfoGovernment to standardize highway signage, the Information
Designer must now perform road construction as well as emergency
road service duties for bewildered travelers.

More than a year has elapsed since the World Wide Web made
national press. We have become experienced InfoTravelers and
have accrued enough frequent Web Surfing Miles allowing us to
recognize by audio-print alone the presidential cat from the
alley variety.
The government-owned car industry (NCSA) with its standard-issue
car (Mosaic) has been privatized resulting in widely divergent
cruising experiences. Since last summer Netscape has introduced
limited 2-D layout, faster access, and low-and-behold: blinking!
However the onus of creating meaningful experiences with information
found on the World Wide Web still rests with its creators and
designers.
As an interaction designer working with professionals creating
information and having to answer to consumers seeking to use
and understand that information I seek to address the following
questions:

What is the difference between information found online and
the same information available in other familiar forms?
How are we interacting with information at each InfoStop
once we get there?

Today, I would like to introduce to you the concept of Information
Playgrounds. I coined this term to describe custom information
experiences constructed for interactive online media such as
the World Wide Web.

Information Playgrounds are:
1. information stops containing one or more live documents,
2. sharing a single coherent metaphor of use,
3. ideally containing encapsulated interactions,
4. presenting a well-defined scope of activity,
5. and producing tangible results.

While the search goes on for an all-encompassing Unified Interaction
Metaphor Theory, distributed information webs demonstrate the
need and appropriateness for multiple local access metaphors.
Interactions are manifestations of how we perceive information.
An ideal playground will make a single trip across the Web, from
server to browser, complete with all its interactivity. Not a
spreadsheet - but how about a calculator? Not a chess game -
but how about Solitaire? Once inside a playground, users assume
a single interaction metaphor. Operating accordingly, they expect
a concise set of 'things to do': here I can search and retrieve
abstracts; this is a music library; and this is a candy shop,
now I can order some brownies.
It is the experience of 'playing' with live information over
time, tweeking it, poking it here, test-casing it there, that
users take with them from an Information Playground. Users seek
validation by extracting information they already know. They
are then willing to TRUST results to questions whose answers
they didn't know. Combining live information with time spent
by users interacting with it produces information experiences,
which are the tangible results of Information Playgrounds.
Since each Information Playgrounds has its own rules, look,
feel, and clientele, the independent, colorful, multi-facet spirit
of the World Wide Web is preserved. At the same time it is possible
to package widely varying Information Playgrounds and 'bind'
them, if you will, into published volumes of interactive information
representing large organizations communicating with diverse visitor
bases.
Using overhead and online examples my talk:

will point the dissonance in metaphors found between InfoSpace
and Desktops mentioned in the abstract from last summer,
highlight some differences between information found online
and that found in other mediums,
describe navigation metaphors used to 'bind' diverse information
sources and 'publish' them on the World Wide Web,
and focus on the design challenges and potential of Information
Playgrounds.


Eviatar (Ev) Shafrir, M.Sc. (Scorpio, born 1958) is a visual
interaction designer with the User Interaction Design group at
Hewlett-Packard in Sunnyvale, California. He holds a B.Sc. degree
in Mathermatics and Computer Science from the Hebrew University
of Jerusalem and a M.Sc. degree in Engineering Management from
Stanford University. He is the senior designer reponsible for
the visual appearance and behavior of Access
HP.
His design interests include non-latin screen-font creation,
custom software components, and off-the-wall visual metaphors
for hard-to-swallow software interfaces. Ev is a member of SIGCHI
and of the Association for Software Design. His latest co-authored
article regarding online information design titled "Blazing
the Trail" appears in the January 1995 issue (volume
27 number 1) of the SIGCHI Bulletin.