CS547 Human-Computer Interaction Seminar   (Seminar on People, Computers, and Design)

Fridays 11:30am-12:30pm PT · Gates B3 · Open to the public
Previous | Next
David Kirsh
UC San Diego
What can HCI learn from Architecture about interaction?
January 17, 2020

Architects design structures for people to dwell in, to inhabit. They support social as well as physical interaction. HCI, so far, has concentrated on designing interfaces primarily for people to monitor and control systems. The two fields – HCI and Architecture - operate with different notions of what an interface is and what interaction means.

I begin with a quick look at the properties of interfaces and the concept of interaction those
properties support. This shows that there are fundamental differences in the nature of interfaces and interaction found in three types of human-system engagement:

1. Direct manipulation,
2. Network, and
3. Architectural or ecological.

My main point is that we need to adopt a niche notion of interaction where we are part of an ecology, not on the other side of an `interface' through which we interact. Ecological interaction is more complex, multi-relational and interesting. And niches cannot be defined independently of the agent or agents who inhabit the niche.

For HCI and AI to reach its potential, it must be tune in to the social cognition of humans. It must be able to negotiate, share in situation awareness, participate in joint activity, feel or understand emotions, and understand enough about human experience to support positive experience. This is a different sort of interaction than HCI or AI historically has focused on.


David Kirsh is Professor and past chair of the Dept. of Cognitive Science at UCSD. He received a D. Phil. (Oxford), did post-doctoral work at MIT (AI Lab), and held research and Visiting Professor positions at MIT and Stanford Univ. He has written on situated and embodied cognition, how environments can be shaped to simplify/extend cognition, and how space, external representations, our bodies and even manipulable objects become interactive tools for thought. He is currently part time Visiting Professor at the Bartlett School of Architecture UCL, he is Adjunct Prof at Trinity Laban Conservatoire of Music and Dance, London, and President Elect of the Academy of Neuroscience for Architecture. He is currently working on a new
theory of interaction and visual reasoning.