CS547 Human-Computer Interaction Seminar   (Seminar on People, Computers, and Design)

Fridays 11:30am-12:30pm PT · Gates B3 · Open to the public
Previous | Next
Paul Pangaro
Sun Microsystems
The Cybernetics of HCI: A Pragmatic Approach
February 15, 2002

A discussion of cybernetics for HCI is pragmatic by nature
because cybernetics is a "science of interactions"
for which human-computer interaction is a subset. The ability
of cybernetics to model the progression and limitations of human
communications holds insight for difficult problems such as HCI
design.
As we all know, semantic information processing by machine
hasn't yet been achieved and today's technology is incapable
of conversing with humans. Human-computer interaction
is a means to the end of human-to-human exchange (messaging),
human-to-team (collaborative work), or human-to-self (learning).
One could paraphrase the goal of HCI therefore as supporting
effective human-through-computer interaction. Interactions
of hands and eyes to input and screen are necessary but unfortunate
intermediations. What we want are our wants to be manifest. With
its practical tools for modeling purpose, feedback, and autonomy,
cybernetics has something to offer.
Early cybernetics was responsible for the now-common but once
startling and revolutionary word "feedback", along
with the first electronic "turtles", and the first
"learning machines." From the 1940s it held an even-handed
consideration for either organic or machine embodiments of intelligence.
Neural nets arose here. In the 1950s, with the ascendancy of
the programmable computer and its theoretical equivalencies to
the nervous system, the fathers of cybernetics begat the fathers
of artificial intelligence. Then cybernetics turned inward to
consider the purpose, feedback functions, and limitations of
cybernetics itself -- that is, to observe human observing. With
the 1960s it grew into an applied epistemology, a discipline
whose modeling tools would crack the conundrum of subjectivity
in a scientific frame.
With a sketch of theory and a smattering of screenshots, this
talk will position cybernetics as a means to sharpen understanding
of human-through-computer interactions in terms of:

conversation, defined as the rise and evolution of distinctions
in a semantic space; and its dual,
intelligence, defined as a property of a system that can
assert, achieve, and modify its goals.

Today's technology isn't doing much talking, but there is
no a priori reason why conversations with an artifact
cannot be achieved. The key is a prescriptive model for innovation,
which is possible in today's cybernetics at least at an architectural
level. At the implementation level, it is a matter of when, not
if.


Paul Pangaro is a
software designer and performer. At MIT he programmed computer-graphics
on vector displays and one of the earliest color raster-scan
machines, the latter at Negroponte's research lab in the mid-70s.
The disconnect between symbolic programming and human expression
forced an inquiry that led to a Ph.D. in cybernetics from Brunel
University (UK). He founded a bi-continent software development
company to build hypertext browsers with fine-grained adaptation
to user goals and learning styles, under contract to US and UK
agencies in the mid-80s. Pangaro was engaged by clients such
as Du Pont and Lotus Development Corp to consider wider questions
about the role of information technology in what is now called
"the new economy." In dot-com startups he worked as
CTO and prototyped desktop knowledge navigators. He is currently
Senior Director at Sun Microsystems where he manages the group
that delivers content and services to developers.