John Morkes
Trilogy Software
Effects of Humor in Task-Oriented Human-Computer Interaction and Computer-Mediated Communication: A Direct Test of SRCT Theory
February 25, 2000
The use of humor is becoming more prevalent in people's interactions
with computers. (Recent examples are Microsoft's Office Assistant
and the application "electronic
Laugh Out Loud,"). However, little published research
exists on whether humor is a positive or a negative in task-oriented
human-computer interaction (HCI). The prevailing notion is that
humor distracts users, wastes their time, and may cause them
to take their work less seriously. Four experiments examined
the effects of successful and unsuccessful humor in task situations
involving HCI and computer-mediated communication (CMC). The
studies used the same between-subjects design and essentially
the same experimental method. Data from the studies were compared
in a direct test of the Social Responses to Communication Technologies
(SRCT) claim that people respond to humans and computers in identical
ways.
Experiments 1 and 2 each had a 2-condition (successful humor
or control) between-subjects design. In the first experiment,
participants worked on a task, ostensibly with another person
in a different room, via a networked computer (CMC). All participants
received preprogrammed comments, differing only in whether they
contained humor. Humor participants rated the "other person"
as more likable and reported greater cooperation with and similarity
to the "other person." They also made more jokes and
responded more sociably. Task time and the amount of effort
participants put into the task were unaffected by humor. In
the second experiment, participants were told they were interacting
with a computer in another room (HCI). The results from Experiment
2 were generally consistent with those from Experiment 1. However,
HCI participants were less sociable, demonstrated less mirth,
felt less similar to their interaction partner, and spent less
time on the task. The results suggest both that humor may enhance
likability of an interface?without distracting users?and that
SRCT theory should be revised.
Experiments 3 and 4 replicated and extended the first two
experiments, with additional measures and conditions that used
jokes seen as unfunny. For each of these experiments, a 3-condition
(successful humor, unsuccessful humor or control) between-subjects
design was used. Results from the CMC study, Experiment 3, were
mostly consistent with those from Experiment 1, and they showed
few differences between measures for the unsuccessful-humor and
control groups. New measures showed no effects for negative
affect or recall memory, but the unsuccessful-humor group responded
more unsociably than the others. The Experiment 4 results were
generally consistent with those from Experiment 3 and SRCT theory.
But comparisons of the data from the HCI and CMC experiments
showed that compared to HCI participants, CMC participants felt
more similar to their interaction partner, were more sociable,
demonstrated more mirth and more negative affect, and liked their
partner less, again suggesting a revision to the SRCT model.
The talk will include a discussion of the study's implications
for interaction design and SRCT theory, examples of humor in
user interfaces, and guidelines for the use of humor in HCI.
This talk is based on a paper (by John Morkes, Hadyn K. Kernal
and Clifford Nass) accepted for publication in the journal Human-Computer
Interaction.
|
John Morkes is the director of the Human-Computer Interaction
Group at Trilogy Software,
a provider of business-to-consumer and business-to-business e-commerce
software. He has a Ph.D. in Communication Theory and Research
from Stanford.
|
|